Lead Shot Still Controversial 20 Years Later

Lead shotFor 20 years now, lead shot hasn't legally left the barrel of a shotgun pointed at a duck or goose in America. But not everyone's breaking out the confetti and cake to celebrate. It's a 20-year anniversary for 2011 that still spurs controversy over whether the loss of top-notch, affordable and gun-safe ammunition was worth the number of potential birds saved after the nationwide lead ban took effect in 1991.

From the perspective of Ken Richkus, chief of the Branch of Population and Habitat Assessment in the Division of Migratory Bird Management at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the benefits of the ban are clear.

"We're looking at about a million to a million and a half ducks a year, in general, that do not die from lead poisoning due to the ban on lead shot," Richkus said. "That's relative to what we saw in the 1980s."

Twenty years allowed the environment to grow around the former lead pellets that still dot the marshes, fields, ponds and forests where the waterfowl roam. Now, the existing lead pellets have been further diluted, and the chances of a bird picking up those pellets are a lot less.


This all sounds well and good, but considering the clean kills that lead shot so efficiently made on waterfowl, one can't help but question whether the crippling rate has increased with these ammo alternatives. To break down the numbers, Richkus said the USFWS looks at the annual harvest inventory program surveys (HIPs), which waterfowlers voluntarily fill out following a season.


Specifically, the survey asks how many birds were knocked down but not retrieved to gather an idea of crippling loss. Of course, because it's an open-ended question, it's open to interpretation — even the definition of a cripple is debatable. But the surveys are the simplest way to obtain crippling data, Richkus said, and because they're conducted regularly, comparisons can be easily drawn up.


Based on these generalizations, the crippling rate from the 1950s up through the mid-1980s was about 20 percent for waterfowl. When the lead ban began being phased in in 1987, Richkus said they actually saw those numbers increase to about 23 or 24 percent through the early 1990s; some hunters feel it was even higher. Then a few years after the ban took effect, the crippling rate dropped to normal rates again, claims Richkus.

"What you're seeing there is when steel was first implemented, it took hunters some time to get used to the new ammunition and be able to adjust their shots accordingly," Richkus noted. "A couple years after the ban, we're back to the 18, 19 percent crippling rates."

That number declined even further to about 14 percent recently, which Richkus credits to any number of factors that aren't certain yet without more research.


"It could be due to better ammunition alternatives, or hunting tools like roboducks bringing birds in closer so hunters have an easier time killing those birds," he said.

To further celebrate the 20th anniversary of lead shot getting shot down, ammo manufacturers are still introducing effective non-toxic options in abundance. More modern materials in shotshells like tungsten and bismuth have made for dense, high-velocity ammo options, but steel is still the most common for waterfowling. As a result, hunters down ducks with steel with a bit more ease than before. Waterfowlers have learned that they can't just take shots at 60 or 70 yards, Richkus said.

"In the last few years, the crippling rates for ducks are the lowest since we started keeping track in the mid-1950s," he added.


Recommended for You

To date, Ducks Unlimited has played a role in conserving 14 million acres. Industry

Ducks Unlimited: A Duck Man's Best Friend

David Hart

To date, Ducks Unlimited has played a role in conserving 14 million acres.

Take it from a pro: Less is more. For Dogs

Dog Discipline Tips & Gear

Joe Genzel - June 20, 2019

Take it from a pro: Less is more.

The sweet, tangy flavor of orange juice combined with spicy jalapeños in this duck recipe will have your taste buds screaming for more. Recipes

Sweet Jalapeño Grilled Duck Recipe

Scott Leysath, "The Sporting Chef"

The sweet, tangy flavor of orange juice combined with spicy jalapeños in this duck recipe will...

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Arkansas Snow Geese

Arkansas Snow Geese

Wildfowl Editor Skip Knowles took this short video showing all the Snow Geese flying. Let's just say, he had a very good hunt!

Cowboy Fernandez Commemorative Yentzen Classic Duck Call

Cowboy Fernandez Commemorative Yentzen Classic Duck Call

As Groves, Texas duck call maker Sure-Shot Game Calls celebrates their 60th anniversary during 2019, company CEO Charlie Holder shows off the limited edition Yentzen Classic aimed at commemorating the life and times of company founder Jim 'Cowboy' Fernandez. With a special autographed box and a laser engraved call body, the Cowboy Classic is a perfect way to honor the legacy of the 1959 world duck calling champ and inventor of the double-reed duck call.

Swedish Duck Hunt

Swedish Duck Hunt

Kevin Steele takes part in a family driven duck hunt in Sweden.

See more Popular Videos

Trending Stories

Consistency is what pushes today's shotshell makers to constantly improve new waterfowl loads Ammo

11 Best New Shotshell Loads For Waterfowl

Wildfowl Online Staff - August 17, 2017

Consistency is what pushes today's shotshell makers to constantly improve new waterfowl loads

While there's no guarantee they'll make you a better shot, these 8 newly-designed shotgun choke Accessories

8 Best Choke Tubes for 2017

Wildfowl Online Staff - October 25, 2017

While there's no guarantee they'll make you a better shot, these 8 newly-designed shotgun...

Author John M. Taylor has broken down the top waterfowl shotguns for the 2018 season. Shotguns

Best Waterfowl Shotguns of 2018

John Taylor - September 25, 2018

Author John M. Taylor has broken down the top waterfowl shotguns for the 2018 season.

See More Stories

More Politics

In 1991, the average price for a gallon of gas was $1.23; a gallon of milk was just $2.36; and a Politics

Read & React: Senate Bill to Raise the Price of Duck Stamp

Kyle Wintersteen - February 14, 2014

In 1991, the average price for a gallon of gas was $1.23; a gallon of milk was just $2.36; and...

This past Spring, North'America's waterfowl did the same thing they've done for centuries: Politics

USFWS Sets Waterfowling Limits Before the Hatch

P.J. Reilly - June 21, 2016

This past Spring, North'America's waterfowl did the same thing they've done for centuries:

For 20 years now, lead shot hasn't legally left the barrel of a shotgun pointed at a duck or goose Politics

Lead Shot Still Controversial 20 Years Later

Angela Pham - December 20, 2011

For 20 years now, lead shot hasn't legally left the barrel of a shotgun pointed at a duck or...

See More Politics

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.