Skip to main content

'Dead Hens Don't Lay Eggs': Should Hunters Shoot Female Ducks?

Hen_001In 1989, Delta Waterfowl adopted a program that encouraged hunters to shoot fewer hens, called "Voluntary Restraint." It came on the heels of a string of poor hatches and a sharp drop in overall duck numbers. The goal was to boost survival of hens and ultimately rebuild duck populations on the backs of those additional females that survived hunting season. Since then, a legion of hunters turned voluntary restraint into a religion. Not only do they refuse to shoot a hen, they chastise others who pull the trigger on anything but a drake.

Whether a result of peer pressure or a conservation ethic, there is no question hunters are selective about what they shoot. A 1991 survey of Illinois waterfowlers showed 74 percent avoid shooting hen mallards. According to wing survey data, hunters kill between two to three drake mallards for every hen they harvest. That ratio has been relatively stable for at least 20 years.

But what about ducks whose sexes look alike? Male and female black ducks are nearly impossible to distinguish, which explains why an equal number of each gender are killed each year. Based on the "dead hens don't lay eggs" mantra used by so many conservation-minded hunters, it would seem logical that black duck populations would be struggling. But they aren't. Although black duck populations are well below long-term averages, due largely to the continued loss of winter habitat, their numbers have been relatively stable for the past 15 years.

There are no studies that have specifically examined the effects of VR on duck populations, but many biologists agree it has little measurable effect.


"If you look at species with sex-specific harvest restrictions — and there's only one: mallards — you will see that there are no discernible differences in long-term population trends compared to species that don't have sex-specific harvest restrictions," says Louisiana Department of Fisheries and Wildlife waterfowl study leader Larry Reynolds.


That is because hunting plays a minor role in duck mortality. Graphs of most duck populations generally follow the same zigzag pattern as the amount of water on the primary nesting grounds. So does the number of ducks killed by hunters. Good nesting conditions in the spring, not a decline in harvest the previous fall, equal more birds.

"Studies have shown that hunting-specific mortality of hen mallards is about 7 or 8 percent. In other words, 93 percent of all hen mallards are unaffected by hunting regulations. The annual mortality rate from all causes is about 40-45 percent for hen mallards, and thus hunting accounts for probably less than 20 percent of annual mortality," says Reynolds.

But even if hunters take just a small percentage of hens, wouldn't shooting fewer females boost duck numbers in the long run? Reynolds points to the various periods when harvest regulations were restrictive, moderate and liberal, including a long period when the limit on mallards in the Pacific Flyway was seven. All of those seven could be hens. That changed in 1984 when duck populations slipped from near-record highs around 1980 to near-record lows five years later, thanks to a series of dry years in the nesting grounds. What was once a liberal bag limit went to a restrictive one; hunters were allowed just one hen mallard. Instead of voluntary restraint, hunters were practicing mandatory restraint. Forced or voluntary, the results were the same.

"Based on the idea that shooting fewer hens means more ducks the following year, we should have been covered up in mallards in the years after the bag limit was reduced. That wasn't the case," says Reynolds. "Populations generally follow nesting conditions. In dry years, duck numbers go down and in wet years, they go up."


Reynolds says hunting plays a smaller role than most think in the overall mortality of hens and that many hunters are looking only at individual birds instead of the overall population. Survival doesn't stimulate duck numbers. Nest success and recruitment, driven largely by the abundance of water, matters most.

Dr. Jim Sedinger, a professor of wildlife ecology at the University of Nevada-Reno, examined duck harvest and its impact on overall populations and found no correlation between harvest rates and duck survival rates. He did, however, find that the higher the overall population of ducks, the lower the survival rate. Harvest, in other words, is compensatory, not additive, which means that those ducks (or the subset of ducks) killed by hunters would have died anyway. Hunting mortality is not added to the other mortality factors.

Hen_002He cited a study that examined pintail band recovery data for 30 years of liberal regulations and 30 years of restrictive regulations. Similar to Reynolds' observations, Sedinger said pintail numbers did not increase following a significant change in bag limits that reduced the hen harvest, even though overall harvest rates fell by half. Prior to the 1983 season, hunters were allowed seven pintails and all of them could be hens. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service dropped the daily bag limit to two pintails, of which only one could be a hen.


"We should have seen an increase in survival rates, but we didn't," says Sedinger. "The same number of ducks were dying (from all causes) after the bag limits changed. There was no impact on survival rates despite a decline in overall harvest."

Sedinger says many hunters and even some wildlife managers miss the purpose of hunting regulations and bag limits.

"We are trying to regulate survival, not recruitment. Those are two completely different things," he adds. "We have to look at the population as a whole, not just individual birds. Duck populations are highly prolific under good wetland conditions and have the capacity for rapid increase even if harvest rates were too high for a short period."

In other words, shoot a hen if you feel like it. But if you don't, lay off the guy who chooses to add some brown to his duck strap.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

Cowboy Fernandez Commemorative Yentzen Classic Duck Call

Cowboy Fernandez Commemorative Yentzen Classic Duck Call

As Groves, Texas duck call maker Sure-Shot Game Calls celebrates their 60th anniversary during 2019, company CEO Charlie Holder shows off the limited edition Yentzen Classic aimed at commemorating the life and times of company founder Jim 'Cowboy' Fernandez. With a special autographed box and a laser engraved call body, the Cowboy Classic is a perfect way to honor the legacy of the 1959 world duck calling champ and inventor of the double-reed duck call.

Arkansas Snow Geese

Arkansas Snow Geese

Wildfowl Editor Skip Knowles took this short video showing all the Snow Geese flying. Let's just say, he had a very good hunt!

Browning A5 Shotgun -

Browning A5 Shotgun - 'Gun Stories'

Gun Stories host Joe Mantegna talks about the origin and history of the Browning A5 shotgun.

Swedish Duck Hunt

Swedish Duck Hunt

Kevin Steele takes part in a family driven duck hunt in Sweden.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Jim Orth needed'a simple blind for hunting Lake St. Clair. A staffing recruiter and outfitter fromBuilding a Duck Boat Blind on a Budget How-To

Building a Duck Boat Blind on a Budget

Mike Marsh - May 10, 2016

Jim Orth needed'a simple blind for hunting Lake St. Clair. A staffing recruiter and outfitter...

Healthy weight is a moving target that you should aim for all season with your duck dog.Achieving a Healthy Weight for Your Duck Dog Retriever

Achieving a Healthy Weight for Your Duck Dog

Tony J. Peterson

Healthy weight is a moving target that you should aim for all season with your duck dog.

Develop the duck dog of your dreams by paying attention to neurological needs.Early Neurological Stimulation for Better Duck Dogs Retriever

Early Neurological Stimulation for Better Duck Dogs

Tony J. Peterson

Develop the duck dog of your dreams by paying attention to neurological needs.

Perfect for party gatherings, these spicy bacon-wrapped poppers come from a Sooner State hunting fan who likes the taste of fresh duck breasts hot off the grill.Bacon-Wrapped Duck Breast Poppers Recipe Recipes

Bacon-Wrapped Duck Breast Poppers Recipe

Lynn Burkhead

Perfect for party gatherings, these spicy bacon-wrapped poppers come from a Sooner State...

See More Trending Articles

More Conservation

It's not that the mallards aren't showing up anymore. Dave Crolick still sees them from his blindMissing Mallards Mystery Conservation

Missing Mallards Mystery

David Hart - September 14, 2016

It's not that the mallards aren't showing up anymore. Dave Crolick still sees them from his...

Unusual weather conditions are expected to bring about top-notch teal hunting.  Big Breeding Numbers, Early Cold Spell Combine to Bring Epic Teal Action Conservation

Big Breeding Numbers, Early Cold Spell Combine to Bring Epic Teal Action

Lynn Burkhead - September 11, 2020

Unusual weather conditions are expected to bring about top-notch teal hunting.

Is it really Is Wind Energy Killing Our Ducks? Conservation

Is Wind Energy Killing Our Ducks?

Joe Genzel

Is it really "great for the environment " if it's bad news for fowl?

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has reported a breeding drop of nearly six percent from 2018.2019 Duck Numbers Still Healthy, But Fall Again Conservation

2019 Duck Numbers Still Healthy, But Fall Again

Lynn Burkhead - August 20, 2019

The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has reported a breeding drop of nearly six percent from...

See More Conservation

Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE Arrow

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Wildfowl App

Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Wildfowl subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now